Project La Fortune
World Class players' solutions to a painting by artist Man Ray



 

Add to Google



 

American surreal artist Man Ray's 1938 painting, "La Fortune" depicts a giant billiard table that projects into a sky rampant with stagy, cotton-candy clouds. This interesting master piece has been on display on the 4th floor of Whitney Museum of American Art from June to September 2006. Adjacent to the painting there is a sculpture of a life sized table by Sherrie Levine titled "After Man Ray".

This master piece has been talked about numerous times in art history. However, the shot itself has rarely been discussed. Therefore, we thought it would be an interesting idea to find out the solution from experts.

The Shot

 

At Sang Lee International Open 2006, we asked the attending world class players and experts:

" Consider billiard as a moving artform and you as an artist, what's your solution to this? "


(Clicking on the picture will open the layout on CueTable)

 

Very interestingly, we have found many different responses. The animation below is a collage of all the answers.

 

 

Artists

 

George Aronek
Michael Bray
Robert Byrne
Frédéric Caudron

Raymond Ceulemans
Dennis Dieckman
Paul Frankel
Carlos Hallon


Bob Jewitt
Kyung-Roul Kim
Pedro Piedrabuena
Semih Sayginer


Mike Shamos
Mazin Shooni
Dirk Snip
Andy Wienk

 

Gallery

 

Knowing each artist's playing style, would you be able to identify the creator for each shot diagram below?

The artist's name has been "Hidden". Place the mouse cursor over the diagram to reveal the name. If you would like to study each diagram closely, simply click on it to open its CueTable layout.


Frédéric Caudron



Raymond Ceulemans



Robert Byrne



Pedro Piedrabuena



George Aronek



Dirk Snip



Dennis Dieckman



Michael Bray



Semih Sayginer



Kyung-Roul Kim



Mike Shamos



Mazin Shooni



Carlos Hallon



Bob Jewitt



Paul Frankel



Andy Wienk

   

 

Interesting Tidbits

How were these layouts assembled?

At Sang Lee International Open 2006, we are fortunate to have a room of world class players. They have displayed their grand performance for the prestige honor and shared their enthusiasm with each other in a family-like manner.

At break time, we approached each player with a single page handout briefly explaining the history and the layout in the painting. A lot of players felt comfortable and drew out their ideal shot right away. Some took it back to their hotel rooms and submitted their ideal solutions later. A few people enjoyed the idea very much and came up with several solutions. Later they narrowed down their collections down to each's "ideal one" (Semih Sayginer offered five. Mike Shamos created four). At the end of each day, we carefully transferred everyone's pen drawings into CueTable format.

Which one is my cue ball?

Since this wasn't indicated in the original painting, our participants could choose either cue ball to shoot from.

Are there similar solutions from different people?

Yes, we have found a couple of these. However, no two are identical. The subtle difference can suggest one of the followings:
1) two different strokes were applied
2) one has different perceptions of the table from the other
3) one's "Normal" playing condition is different from the other's.

Where is Blomdahl's solution?

We have asked Blomdahl, the most courageous player in billiard world today, at the early stage of this project.

"Hmmm, there is not an easy solution to this..." Squinting his eyes as he got into deep thoughts, he carefully replied seriously. "I will need some time to find the best answer..."

We will check with him again soon : )

Articles in NY Times

This tournament has been covered in the paper on 8.18.06:
Billiards’ Best Spin Doctors Vie in a Three-Cushion Zone by Corey Kilgannon

The show at Whitney Museum has been covered on 6.30.06:
The Whitney's Collection at 75: Culture of Stunning Contradictions by Holland Cotter

*NY Times membership required

 

Billiard in Arts

La Fortune

La Fortune

La Fortune II

 

Later in 1941, Man Ray has made another painting called "La Fortune II". It has a similar position layout with a different landscape under gloomier sky in the background.

For detailed information about Man Ray, Please check: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Man_Ray


Other Famous Paintings with Billiard theme

Billiard had been regarded as a high class activity in many societies around the world for a long time during history. It was widely popular among creative folks and alike.

Night Cafe by Vincent Van Gogh
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vincent_Van_Gogh (artist's bio)

Billiard Room at Menil-Hubert by Edgar Degas
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edgar_Degas (artist's bio)

At the Cafe by Paul Gauguin
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Gauguin (artist's bio)

Billiard Table by Georges Braque
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georges_Braque (artist's bio)

Billiard Players by Varvara Stepanova
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varvara_Stepanova (artist's bio)

 

 

Billiard as Art

 

"It requires one's creative skill and imagination."

A while ago an advanced player tried describing the essence in preparing for a shot.

"In billiard, every stroke is an expression. Sometimes you have to hit a ball hard, you need to transform your whole body into a hammer to achieve the level of intensity. And for a soft shot, you will be flowing as light as a piece of feather."

While a top player is efficient in gaining score points to win a game, he would do so in a graceful manner. Using the table as canvas and the ball as ink, the player constantly has to create a new composition for every shot. This technique is also called "playing for positions". He would carefully ease off each obstacle with precision and innovation. Even during competition play where the intensity is high, this person can always maintain a harmonic rhythm. It all feels like a series of pleasant music notes and soon you find yourself dancing along with everyone in the crowd.

Throughout the years, a few influential thinkers have been able to verbalize their philosophy and enlighten others. Sang Lee is one of these great players. He has once made a profound remark on aiming, which can also be applicable to life,

"Instead of commanding the cue ball to move your way, kindly ask where it feels like going."

 

acknowledgement

We would like to express our gratitude to all our participants who kindly shared their insights and made this project possible.

Special thanks go to Helen Koh, Ira Lee, Charles Brown, Min Jae Pak, Michael Kang and Jan Carl for their kind efforts in organizing Sang Lee International Open 2006.

 

Playing your part

 

Do you have an interesting solution to this shot?

Please include your name, a brief description and send it to us via LaFortune@cuetable.com.
We will list it in LaFortune Blog Page.

We hope you find this page interesting, please forward to a friend.

Let's share ideas and fun!




" I took the one less traveled by,
And that has made all the difference."

- Robert Frost, 1874-1963

 

 

 

 

 

 

  © 2006-2007 CueTable.com